What Modifier 25 Actually Means

​

Per American Medical Association (CPT® definition):

A significant, separately identifiable evaluation and management (E/M) service by the same physician or other qualified healthcare professional on the same day of a procedure or other service.

In plain English:

You performed:

1. An E/M service and

2. A procedure on the same date

And the E/M was:

• Above and beyond

• Not just the pre-procedure assessment

• Not already included in the procedure

​

Where Modifier 25 Is Used

Modifier 25 is used on:

• E/M codes only

  • 99202–99215 (office/outpatient)

  • 99281–99285 (ED)

  • 99221–99223 (hospital inpatient)

  • 99234–99236 (observation)

  • etc.

It is never appended to the procedure code.

​

The Core Rule Most People Get Wrong

Every procedure already includes a “built-in” E/M.

That includes:

• History focused on the procedure

• Brief exam related to the procedure

• Decision to perform a minor procedure (0 or 10 day global)

If your documentation only supports that work —
Modifier 25 is NOT appropriate.

​

When Modifier 25 Is Appropriate

It is appropriate when the E/M includes:

• Evaluation of additional complaints

• Management of chronic conditions

• Medication management unrelated to procedure

• Extensive medical decision making beyond the procedure

• Work that would have stood alone if no procedure were done

Ask this compliance question:

If the procedure were canceled, would the E/M still be billable?

If yes → likely 25
If no → do not append

​

Facility Outpatient Claims

Hospitals also use Modifier 25 on facility E/M codes when appropriate.

However, facilities must follow:

• CMS OPPS rules (for Medicare)

• NCCI edits

• Payer-specific outpatient guidelines

Under Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), documentation must show the E/M was medically necessary and separate from procedural work.

​

Common Real-World Scenarios

Appropriate Example

Patient presents with:

• Chest pain

• Hypertension management

• Receives IV push medication

The evaluation of chest pain + management decision making supports a separate E/M.

Modifier 25 appropriate.

​

NOT Appropriate Example

Patient presents for:

• Laceration repair
  Provider documents:

• Focused exam of wound

• Decision to suture

That evaluation is inherent to the procedure.

Modifier 25 NOT appropriate.

​

Top Audit Triggers

Modifier 25 is heavily audited because it increases reimbursement.

High-risk patterns:

• 25 appended to nearly every E/M

• High-level E/M + minor procedure combo

• ED overuse

• Template-driven documentation

• Same diagnosis on E/M and procedure without separate rationale

Many RAC and payer audits focus specifically on 25.

​

Modifier 25 vs Modifier 57 (Critical Difference)

Modifier 25:

• Used with minor procedures (0 or 10 day global)

• Applies to same-day E/M

Modifier 57:

• Used when E/M results in decision for major surgery (90-day global)

Do not confuse them.

​

Modifier 25 vs Modifier 59

Modifier 25:

• E/M vs procedure

Modifier 59:

• Procedure vs procedure (distinct procedural services)

Completely different purposes.

​

Documentation That Supports Modifier 25

Your note should clearly show:

• Separate complaint OR

• Separate medical decision making OR

• Separate assessment and plan elements

Best practice:

• Separate header or paragraph for E/M

• Clear assessment and plan distinct from procedure note

​

High-Risk Specialties for Modifier 25

• Emergency Medicine

• Urgent Care

• Primary Care

• Dermatology

• Orthopedics

• Pain Management

These specialties frequently perform minor procedures same day.

​

Financial Impact

Modifier 25:

• Allows payment of both E/M and procedure

• Without it, E/M may be bundled

• Incorrect use can trigger:

  • Recoupments

  • Extrapolated audits

  • Fraud allegations if patterned

​

Medicare & NCCI Considerations

Under CMS and the National Correct Coding Initiative (NCCI):

• Edits may bundle E/M with procedures

• Modifier 25 bypasses bundling only when criteria met

• Medical necessity is always required

Improper use can lead to:

• Claim denial

• Post-payment review

• Overpayment demand

​

Best Practice Compliance Checklist

Before appending Modifier 25, confirm:

• E/M is medically necessary

• Documentation supports separate work

• Work is above usual pre/post service care

• Diagnoses support separate services

• Audit risk considered

• Not automatically appended by system

​

The Truth About Modifier 25

It is not:

• A revenue tool

• An automatic append

• A way to maximize reimbursement

It is:

• A compliance-sensitive modifier

• A documentation-dependent decision

• One of the most scrutinized modifiers in outpatient billing